Thinking of Replacing Your Old Toilet? Here’s Why You Should.

Toilets are one of the most used fixtures in the home and can last between 10 and 15 years. While a toilet may require occasional repairs, if yours is in constant need of a plumber it may be time for a new toilet. 

Replacing a toilet doesn’t have to be a headache as long as you’re prepared. There are a number of factors to consider before installing a toilet. The size and shape of the bowl and the type of rough-in required should all be confirmed to ensure the toilet meets all your household needs.  

We’re here to help answer these questions to make the process of changing a toilet go as smoothly as possible. Read on to learn more!

Reasons to Consider Replacing a Toilet

The decision for toilet replacement really depends on your existing toilet’s performance, your household needs and your budget. Below are the three main reasons for replacing a toilet:

It’s Broken or Malfunctioning

Toilet repairs are common. However, you may need to consider replacing a toilet if the problems are frequent and recurring. Some common issues that indicate it’s time for a new toilet include: 

• Constant clogging or flushing issues that do not stop after a repair 

• A cracked bowl or tank: these cracks can cause leaks or damage the structure of your toilet over time 

• The tank won’t stop running 

• Endless repairs: minor fixes do not indicate a significant issue but if your toilet needs constant upkeep it’s time for a new one o You notice the toilet leaking 

• The toilet moves when you sit on it

Bathroom Renovations

A bathroom renovation is another situation where replacing a toilet is either inevitable or desired. You may want to replace your existing toilet if: 

• You’re changing the décor in your bathroom and want a new toilet to match 

• You’re updating your home and want to replace old fixtures 

• You’ve just moved in and are remodeling

Keeping Water Costs Low

Replacing a toilet can also help lower your water costs. If you’ve noticed a spike in your water bills, it may be caused by an old or damaged toilet. Broken toilets need to use more water when flushing to ensure waste goes down the drain.

There are also water-saving toilets that can help lower water bills and reduce your impact on the environment. For example, WaterSense toilets use up to 60% less water when flushing than standard toilets.

Questions to Ask Before Purchasing a New Toilet

Be sure to keep these important factors in mind to ensure you get a unit that works for your family and your space.

What Shape Is Best?

Toilet bowls come in two shapes – round and elongated: 

• Round bowls are more compact, making them ideal for small bathrooms 

• Elongated bowls are two inches longer, making them more comfortable because they offer more thigh support

What Style Do You Prefer?

From colour to tank type to profile, there are a number of different style elements to consider when looking for a new toilet. Check out our Toilet Buying Guide to learn more about the different toilets available.

What Height Do You Need?

Most toilets are available in standard or comfort height: 

• Standard height is 14-15 inches (35.5 to 38 cm) from the ground and is ideal for children and average-height adults 

• Comfort height is 16 inches (40.5 cm) or more and is the best choice for taller and older adults or people with leg and back issues

Where Will the New Toilet Be Used?

Determining where the new toilet will be used helps determine the type of toilet that would work best. For example, a durable standard toilet is ideal for a small powder room that is used frequently. Personal or ensuite bathrooms allow you to choose a specialised or more stylized toilet.

Does Your Bathroom Have Special Plumbing Requirements?

Be sure to take the following plumbing factors into account when purchasing a new toilet to ensure it aligns properly and is easy to install:  

• Check existing pipe sizes and dimensions to make sure they fit the new toilet plumbing 

• Determine the length of the water line and leave enough space to install a shut off valve: this allows you to shut off the water to the toilet without turning off the water for the entire house 

• Check whether or not drain and vent lines need to be installed  

• Verify any local building and plumbing code requirements before changing out a toilet to make sure you stay within the guidelines

Other Factors to Consider

Modern toilets include many new features. Some factors to consider are: 

• Type of flush: you can choose a single-flush toilet, dual-flush toilet or touchless toilet 

• Water saving options: WaterSense or low-flow toilets can help lower water bills 

• Length of rough-in: the rough-in is the distance from the wall to the centre of the toilet drainpipe and is essential to ensure your new toilet fits your space

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Purchasing a New Toilet

It’s easy to get caught up in the process and choose a new toilet that may not actually work in your home. Keep these common mistakes in mind so you can avoid them: 

• Picking the wrong height: be sure to determine which height is most comfortable for you and your family 

• Not measuring the rough-in: this increases the risk of purchasing a new toilet that doesn’t fit or align properly  

• Choosing a toilet with unsuitable flushing power

Whether it’s a necessity or a bathroom décor makeover, replacing a toilet can refresh your space, make your bathroom more comfortable and efficient, and can even help lower your water costs. Take a look at our selection of toilets and accessories to find a model that works best for your bathroom.